Helen and I just watched this charming film again. I wrote the review below when I first watched it, and it still sums up how I feel about it.
Tom.
------
The Science of Sleep
(Minor Spoilers Only)
Lots of people were astonished by Michel Gondry’s marvellous film “The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind”. The Science of Sleep is his follow-up, and this time he wrote as well as directed. Gael Garcia Bernal plays Stephane, a young man who went to Mexico with his father when his parents split, and returns to France from Mexico to stay with his mother in his childhood bedroom because she has found him a job, and after his father has died of cancer. Unfortunately it is not the Graphic Design job he expects but a dull cut-and-paste job with tacky calendars.
He has great difficulty separating reality from his dreams and frequently mixes the two up, with sometimes hilarious results. It’s a quirky comedy and it will be too quirky for some people. The dream sequences are frequent and sometimes lengthy and it is often difficult to be sure if what we are seeing is reality or dream and therein lies some of the charm for me. Mingled in with the dreams are his real thoughts of love for his neighbour, Stephanie, played calmly and sensibly by Charlotte Gainsbourg.
Stephane has a naïve, child-like view of the world and his dreams are the same. Worlds constructed out of cloth, cardboard, cellophane and paper move using stop motion animation in the most lovely manner, and I found these sequences to be both charming and sweet and they really felt as if they had come from the mind of a child. Cloth horses, typewriting spiders, cellophane seas and a boat with paper sails all appear. It is deliberately amateurish, as if children really made the models. Stephane and Stephanie both make things with their hands and seem as if they would be a good match for each other.
There’s a tricky balancing act here. Some will no doubt think that the dream sequences get in the way of the beautifully told but non-reciprocated growing attraction that Stephane has for Stephanie as they work on models together, and some will think that real life intrudes too much on the dreams. I found the balance about right.
In addition to the Stephane/Stephanie interactions we also get to see Stephane at work and although he thinks his job is bad, he really doesn’t realise how lucky he is. His colleagues are funny and the office atmosphere is pleasant. Sometimes we must enjoy what we can and get on with life: things could surely be better but they could also be far worse.
There is also humour in the language mix-ups because Stephane speaks French only poorly, and both Spanish and English better (the film uses all three languages). At one point, Stephane says to Stephanie “I like your tit - I erect in my pants”, or something like that.
The further we get through the film, the more we realise that Stephane isn’t merely child-like in his attitude, he has mental problems, or at least great difficulty in determining what is reasonable behaviour and what isn’t. Completely out of the blue when they aren‘t even a couple, he asks Stephanie to marry him, and he even breaks into her flat while she is out. These are not the acts of a sane adult. Were it not for my growing realization of his poor mental state, no doubt related to his parents’ separation and his father‘s death, it is likely that I could have seen Stephane as an irritating man who needed a good hard slap rather than as touching and sweet. His childishness does sometimes irritate, and on several occasions I wanted to shout at him to get a grip. His mental illness should have been treated and it’s a failing in the film that this isn’t even mentioned. Someone with such a fleeting hold on reality must surely come a serious cropper at some point.
At heart, this is a very human film and it’s subject matter is love. The characters all feel like real people and they talk to each other in the way that real people do. This grounds the film in reality whilst the dream sequences gloriously soar to the heavens. A lovely, sweet and charming film.